Username: 
 Password:

Posted Jan 11, 2007 06:26 by Chris L. Listed in: Opinion & Analysis, iPhone Tags: Sony Ericsson, 3G, Cingular
Ó
9QJ
The fan(boys) want you to be the best ever. So do we - but we want you to be the best OBJECTIVELY.Nothing's perfect at launch - not even Apple. Sure, the iPhone's great and all, but are there some things they might have overlooked that could potentially trip this baby up? Hey, didn't we do this piece already? Yeah, well, it's Ars Technica's turn, and their regular Infinite Loop feature touches on a few potential iPhone misses we've already touched on, and quite a few that we didn't.

So, for the dog that barked: no 3G, costs as much as a PS3, tied to Cingular, and limited memory. Add it all up and it's a potential turnoff for all but the hardest of the Apple die-hards. At least that's the implication: this won't be the "killer app" (as opposed to) the iPod turned out to be.

And the dog that didn't bark. "No over-the-air downloads from iTunes." That would have been a killer feature to include... well, maybe. It's a consequence of lack of 3G support, whose bandwidth would have been necessary for the high-rate transfers that downloading from iTunes will require. Or maybe Apple was looking at prior experiences with phones working with iTunes and decided that it's not worth it. "No Wi-Fi sync with iTunes." Although the Infinite Loop columnist - and we - cover that if the software can support it, why not? Hey, it's probably just a firmware away - and it's a good use for the Internet-browsing Wi-Fi capabilities of the phone.

"No MS Exchange or Office support." For Infinite Loop, "this is a potential biggie to business users." Which is true - if the iPhone was meant to be a PDA to begin with. Here the QJ jury is out. At its price, it might as well have PDA features to attract a bigger customer base, but that will mean that Apple will have to face not only Nokia and Sony Ericsson on the one hand, but also Blackberry and all the other PDA manufacturers on the other. We've never seen Apple have to fight a two-front war on the underdog side before.

"Not extensible by third parties." Infinite Loop says that if Apple locks down the iPhone away from third-party developers, this will hurt the product in the long run. If Apple opens up now, and begins working with developers to at least set a standard for iPhone-compatible software, this will measure up favorably for the iPhone's chances in the market. It could even resolve the "No MS Exchange" issue by offering an alternative.

Finally, "No removable memory." Especially for a product that is essentially a kick-a** iPod, having an 8GB limit is very, very, very, very painful. Then again, what iPod had removable memory, either (of course, they didn't need to have one for the most part, but you get the point, right? 8GB)? We said it before, and we'll say it again: if the PSP can potentially get 32GB of memory all by swapping in a stick, why can't the iPhone have one built-in in the near future? Beefing up the memory is a good justification for pushing the launch date of the phone back - it will be more than worth it in the long run.

[Via Ars Technica] Permalink  |   Email this  |   Linking Blogs   |   Digg It!

Bookmark / Find this article on:

5 Comments


Sort by:
by Advertising -

   
   by neok182 (Unregistered) - 2007-01-11
 » .

Sadly this is all true. for as amazing of a device as it is. it's going to sell to cingular customers who wanted a sidekick or a Q. No business man would use this becasue of it's lack of MS office support and price. where he could get a Q or blackberry for 1/3 the price.

its a great start, but an iPhone2 is really needed with all the features it should have.

and with that said, i dare sony to go add a cell phone into the PSP2.

   Re: matt (Unregistered) - 2007-01-12
 » Sony...No

The iPhone is nothing, neither is the PSP. The iPhone is the beginning. Firmware updates for iTunes streaming to televison are on their way (much like the ps3 and psp were supposed to be able to do...) and soon, blockbuster video is going to be pissed. Renting movies off itunes? Buying them? How about on your iPhone? Office support is in the future, and I don't know how long the exclusive cingular support will last. The ONLY flaw, is the memory. Everything else can be updated, changed, and manipulated. The design is immaculate. The memory is a big deal...But not, at the same time. I'm sorry, but you don't need 10G of music with you at all times. I have a 1G nano and its fine. I put on what i want, make playlists, etc. People want more, but don't need more. What a great phone.
   by hah (Unregistered) - 2007-01-12
 » m

at "250 only the chavs will buy this.

to be frank
   by neok182 (Unregistered) - 2007-01-12
 » .

@matt: your wrong on a few things.

Firmware: yes it can be upgraded, buy i can guarantee you apple wont make any major updates on so you go buy the new one. need i remind anyone that were n the 5th generation of ipods in only a few years.

Cingular: it will never leave Cingular. In case you havn't noticed iTunes phones have always been with cingular and cingular alone. Apple has a deal with them and it's not going to change anytime soon. and since this is a GSM phone, T-Mobile or Alltell would be the only other US providers t get it. And i can pretty much guarantee that T-Mobile will never get it. So it will most likely be cingular and cingular alone forever for any iPhone (unless they make a CDMA one (which would be stupid) for Sprint/Verizon.

iTunes; right now you do much with itunes on the phone. no OTA or wi-fi downloads. However if they do add this then yes it will be nice. but upsetting blockbuster? hell no. For one even on the max speed of wi-fi or EDGE. a movie would take hours to download. when you could go and rent it and pay 4 bucks and get it within a few minutes. OTW downloads will help, but because of how long it will take it wont help much.

Office: They most likely will ad support for this once they realize that no businessmen are buying it. because of that one flaw. and if apple don't add support for it then i personally say that apple shouldn't get anymore software from Microsoft.

It is a good phone. but as has already been stating it's missing a lot. right now it's more of a toy than a phone. and for 600 bucks. thats way too much. With the lack of features and lack of things that they'll do upgrade wise, this really doesn't deserve to be anymore than 400. (or less with rebates)
   by alex (Unregistered) - 2007-01-13
 » alex9999

there are worst phones at that prices xD.... and it runs in OSX... so... all that aplications are matter of time....




You appear as unregistered user now. To change this, you must register or login



Post new comment  Submit a trackback URL
You can't post comments anymore on this article!


powered by
QJ.NET Blog Network RSS Feeds
MyQJ Feed / PDA
MyQJ RSS / PDA
Blog of Blogs Feed / PDA
QJ.NET RSS / PDA
Gaming Consoles Feed / PDA
Nintendo DS RSS / PDA
PlayStation 3 RSS / PDA
PSP Updates RSS / PDA
Wii RSS / PDA
Xbox 360 RSS / PDA
PC Gaming Feed / PDA
Games for Windows RSS / PDA
MMORPG RSS / PDA
Tabula Rasa RSS / PDA
World of Warcraft RSS / PDA
Science Feed / PDA
Science RSS / PDA
Technology Feed / PDA
Apple RSS / PDA
Gadgets RSS / PDA
Mobile RSS / PDA
Photography RSS / PDA
User Favorites - November
Most Commented
No available articles!
User Favorites - November
Top Jumps
No available articles!